By Giselle Avila | October 29, 2026
October is ending with a familiar task on my desk: asking which records exist, which have been provided, and what it will take to obtain the rest.
There have been filings. There have been objections. There has even been a reply. What I still want is a complete accounting that lets me get past the correspondence and examine the evidence.
That distinction matters. A busy case does not necessarily mean an answered question.
The procedural history belongs in the update
On August 31, the federal court dismissed our amended complaint with prejudice for failure to comply with court orders, including attendance at an in-person hearing. I sought revision of that ruling. The same order left Bayport and Yaumara Camacho’s counterclaims active and did not resolve the contempt motion. [1]
That is difficult history, and readers should have it. I am describing what the identified orders and filings say, not announcing a result that the record does not establish.
The defense subsequently sought final judgment on the dismissed claims and conditional dismissal of its counterclaims. On September 23, the day its first production responses were due, it also requested a discovery stay. Its October 16 response describes objections served on September 23 and 28 and asks the court to address the requested stay and dismissal before requiring further discovery. [2]
The defense argues that some discovery may become unnecessary and that certain requests are too broad or disproportionate. My concern is what that proposed sequence means for a person still facing claims: the accusations remain part of the case described in those filings while access to information about them remains disputed.
As of its October 16 filing, the defense said the stay request was undecided. That dated statement should not be mistaken for a certification of the docket on every day afterward.

Four providers, and a need for an itemized account
The October 16 provider response said Automattic and Namecheap had produced records, while Google and Squarespace had not. The defense also said it forwarded received productions the same day and did not oppose providing copies of returns or tailored protection for personal identifiers. Those are the defense’s representations as of that filing. [3]
I have acknowledged receiving materials. My question is whether the accounting is complete.
On October 22 and 23, I requested specifics: what each provider had delivered, when it arrived, what had been supplied to me, and what remained outstanding. I also sought relevant nonprivileged provider communications and answers about disputed party discovery. The October 26, 5 p.m. Central response time was my requested conferral deadline, not an order from the court. [4]
An itemized answer would allow the parties to identify what is actually left to resolve. Another general disagreement leaves that work undone.
The October 28 reply
On October 27, I proposed a motion concerning document subpoenas to SOS BTY Group, LLC, Black Dog Forensics, LLC, and a laboratory that tested Bayport products. The proposal also addressed Marshal service without prepaid fees and a procedure for later document subpoenas, subject to objections. [5]
The following afternoon, Gregory Deans replied:
“We are opposed to relief sought in your proposed motion.”
That established his position. It did not identify the reason for it.
The proposal combined several requests, and I had not attached completed subpoenas or detailed document schedules. His response therefore does not establish that he reviewed a particular laboratory-results demand and rejected it. It leaves open whether the objection concerned the records, the service arrangements, the future procedure, or more than one of those subjects.
I asked him to explain and offered to narrow the request to one or two subpoenas. The retrieved thread contains no substantive explanation answering that follow-up. The correspondence reviewed through October 29 also did not reveal an itemized response resolving my October 23 questions. That describes the material reviewed, not every possible communication channel. [5]
Bayport had pursued records about me through online providers. I wanted a workable route to third-party records too. If a proposed route is objectionable, identifying the problem would give me something concrete to address.

What I want next
I want the remaining issues reduced to records, specific objections, and dates. I want to know what can be produced, what is disputed, and why.
I experience the unresolved exchanges as delay. The defense describes its requested sequencing as a way to avoid unnecessary discovery and expense. Readers can evaluate both positions without treating either party’s description as a finding by the court.
The month may be almost over. The questions are still on the table.
Source notes
[1] Garcia et al. v. Bayport Laboratories, LLC et al., No. 4:25-cv-03676, ECF 200, August 31, 2026, p. 7 and footnote 2; ECF 206, request for revision.
[2] ECF 245, October 16, 2026, pp. 1–4, describing ECF 228 and 233, response dates, objections, and the requested sequence. Conditional dismissal without prejudice was requested; this article does not describe that request as an entered dismissal.
[3] ECF 244, October 16, 2026, pp. 4 and 10. The provider status and forwarding statements are attributed to the defense and tied to that date.
[4] October 22 and 23, 2026 conferral correspondence, including the October 23 acknowledgment of received materials.
[5] October 27, 2026 conferral; Deans’s October 28 response at 4:58 p.m. Central; Giselle’s follow-up at 7:53 p.m. Central. SOS BTY Group, LLC is the name used in the conferral, without an independent determination of the entity’s legal identity. The proposal contemplated January 15, 2027 production. No completed subpoenas or detailed schedules were attached.
This is a personal account of identified filings and correspondence through October 29. The opposition to my proposal does not establish what any laboratory records contain, and the outstanding disputes are not presented as adjudicated misconduct.
Artwork: AI-generated editorial illustration. It does not depict an actual facility, document, laboratory result, or transaction.

Related coverage: Bayport Labs dispute timeline · public court dockets.

Comments